Cooking with Pino Di Benedetto | Settebello
Meet Pino Di Benedetto of Settebello at the Italian Club Bedfordview. Discover his Neapolitan food philosophy, music career and passion for authentic Italian cooking.
With a love of Napoli, a healthy disregard for food rules and absolutely no time for pineapple on pizza, Pino Di Benedetto brings plenty of passion and personality to the table at Settebello, at the Italian Club Bedfordview. But there’s more to this outspoken Italian than pasta and pizza. A former music industry heavyweight who spent 28 years working with some of the biggest names in the business, Pino has swapped recording studios for restaurant kitchens, bringing the same passion, creativity and flair to food. We chat about family traditions, proper Italian cooking, music, Maradona and why Sunday lunch without pasta simply isn’t Sunday!
Cooking with Pino Di Benedetto
Your fondest food memory?
My fondest memory was helping my dad in the restaurant he owned in Braamfontein called Valle Verde, I use to help him shape the pizza balls and serve customers.
What inspired you to cook?
The love of food I guess. My father, and because I had too, my mom and dad worked so when we got back from school we either cooked or did not eat, slowly slowly I started to love it.
Which South African dish deserves more respect?
For me, it has to be samp and beans. It’s a beautiful, honest dish with so much history and character. As an Italian, I see similarities with our traditional cucina povera humble ingredients, cooked with patience, that deliver incredible flavour. In Italy, we’ve learnt to celebrate these dishes as part of our culinary identity. I think South Africa should do more of the same. Great food doesn’t have to be expensive or complicated, it just needs soul.
What is the biggest misconception about cooking for other people?
I think the biggest misconception is that cooking for other people is simply about making good food. It’s so much more than that. Growing up Italian, food was always about bringing people together, creating memories and making people feel welcome. You can have the finest ingredients and the most beautifully presented plate, but if there’s no passion or generosity behind it, something is missing. For me, cooking is an act of love and hospitality. It’s not just about what you put on the plate, but how you make people feel around the table. That’s the philosophy we try to live by every day at Settebello.
If you weren’t a chef, what would you be?
Funny enough, I’ve already lived that dream! Food has always been my first passion, but life took me on an incredible 28 year journey through my second passion, music. I had the privilege of working with some of the biggest names both internationally and locally, discovering and signing numerous artists along the way. I went on to run what I still believe was the greatest music company in the world, EMI Music South Africa, before ending my music career at Universal Music. And then, as life would have it, I came full circle, back to where my heart had always been food. When I look back, music and food aren’t that different. Both are about passion, creativity, emotion and bringing people together. I’ve been incredibly fortunate to have lived two dreams in one lifetime, but food was always where my heart belonged.
What’s your pet peeve in restaurants?
My biggest pet peeve is the overuse of the word ‘authentic’. Every second Italian restaurant claims to be authentically Italian, yet you look at the menu and find dishes from every corner of the world! You wouldn’t walk into a traditional restaurant in Italy and expect to find espetada on the menu, would you? Authenticity isn’t a marketing slogan, it’s about respecting the cuisine, its ingredients, its traditions and its identity. At Settebello, we take that seriously. We don’t serve feta when there’s beautiful Italian robiola, and you certainly won’t find chicken or pineapple on our pizza menu! Now, if you really insist on having it, we’ll probably make a plan, but believe me, you’re going to pay dearly for it!”
Your worst kitchen disaster?
My worst kitchen disaster? It happens almost every weekend! A table of 20 or more guests who insist on ordering à la carte, despite us explaining that it’s almost impossible to get 20 different dishes, all cooked perfectly, out of the kitchen at exactly the same time. We always recommend family style dining or a beautiful harvest table, which is exactly how Italians love to eat sharing food, passing plates around and enjoying the occasion together. But no, there’s always that one table that insists on doing things their way! Suddenly the kitchen is in chaos, the chefs are performing miracles, and everyone expects their food at the same time. It’s organised madness! My advice? When an Italian tells you to eat family style, trust him. He knows what he’s talking about
What’s your go-to recipe at home?
Rigatoni Ragu, rich slow cooked pasta with a sauce made from sausage, beef short rib, pork short rib ….brings me back to waking up on a Sunday morning and smelling what Nonna was cooking.



Your favourite dish to cook?
Don’t really have one, I love cooking things that have few ingredients and making each ingredient shine on its own, the Margherita pizza is one of them, perfect blend of 5 ingredients.
Your favourite dish to eat?
I have so many favourites! It really depends on the time of day, the day of the week and even the mood I’m in. But one thing is non negotiable Sunday lunch has to include pasta! It’s an Italian tradition that’s deeply ingrained in me. A Sunday without pasta simply isn’t Sunday. It’s about family, sitting around the table, sharing stories, enjoying good food and taking your time. That’s how I grew up, and some traditions are just too important to ever change!
Your favourite ingredient?
Olive oil.
Favourite cuisine?
Other than Neapolitan I would say Portuguese or Spanish.
Favourite kitchen utensil?
The wooden spoon.
An ingredient we’d never find in your kitchen?
Micro herbs, edible flowers and coriander.
What’s one food rule you happily break?
I’m a traditionalist when it comes to Italian food, and I believe certain recipes and ingredients should be respected. But here’s the thing food is meant to be enjoyed, not governed by the food police! If you want to put Parmesan on your seafood pasta, I’ll probably shake my head, and if you ask for a cappuccino after dinner, I’ll definitely raise an eyebrow. But at the end of the day, you’re the one eating it, not me! Just don’t ask me to put pineapple on your pizza and expect me to smile about it!
What do you do on your day off?
Stay home with the family and cook for them.
Who would you invite to your ultimate dinner party?
Without a doubt, Diego Armando Maradona and Pino Daniele. Two absolute legends who represent everything I love about Napoli. Maradona gave an entire city hope, pride and the belief that anything was possible, while Pino Daniele gave Napoli its soundtrack, its soul and its voice. One was a magician with a football, the other with a guitar. Can you imagine the stories around that dinner table? Good Neapolitan food, plenty of wine, laughter, football, music and probably a few arguments! I wouldn’t even need to invite anyone else. Just those two would make it the greatest dinner party of my life. For a Neapolitan like me, it doesn’t get any better than that!
What is your #1 tip for reducing food waste at home?
Purchase what you will eat on the day from your local green grocer, butcher etc…don’t buy food and store like its the end of the world.
If you were a dish or cocktail, what would you be?
Im round at the waist so would have to be a pizza.
Tell us something people might be surprised to know about you.
Most people know me as the passionate, sometimes loud Italian behind Settebello, but very few realise that I spent 28 years in the music industry, working with some of the biggest artists in the world, discovering talent and running EMI Music before finishing my career at Universal Music. I’ve gone from dealing with rock stars and recording studios to chefs, pizza ovens and restaurant kitchens! And believe me, the personalities in a restaurant kitchen can be just as demanding as those in the music industry! The funny thing is, I wouldn’t change a single moment of either journey.
Visit www.settebello.co.za